A lawsuit accusing former Robbinsville Mayor David Fried of retaliating against a longtime township administrator who reported sexual harassment and questioned municipal hiring practices has ended in a $300,000 settlement.
Township Council voted 4-0 on Thursday, Oct. 8, to settle the lawsuit filed in July 2024 by former Township Administrator Joy Tozzi under New Jersey’s whistleblower law. Councilman Amit Chopra abstained because he had not attended the executive session in which the matter was discussed.
Under the agreement, $25,000 of the settlement is allocated to alleged lost wages, $150,807.19 to claimed mental, physical and emotional injuries, and $124,192.81 to attorney fees and costs.
The settlement resolves the lawsuit without a trial or determination of wrongdoing. The township and Fried have denied the allegations, and the agreement expressly states that the payment is not an admission of liability or misconduct.
Tozzi, who is now the township manager for East Windsor, began working for Robbinsville in February 2008 as a constituent relations specialist. She subsequently served in human resources and as assistant township administrator before being appointed township administrator in 2013.
Her lawsuit alleged that problems began in November 2021, when she and other municipal employees raised concerns about the behavior of then-Councilman Ron Witt.
According to the complaint filed in Mercer County Superior Court, Witt made sexually inappropriate comments to township employees, including Tozzi, whom he allegedly referred to by a sexually suggestive nickname.
The lawsuit also alleged that Witt drank excessively and behaved inappropriately toward male and female municipal employees. Tozzi claimed she reported the conduct to Fried and several Township Council members.
According to the complaint, the township conducted an investigation that substantiated the allegations against Witt. However, Tozzi said that no disciplinary action followed. She further claimed that Fried told her Witt was his “best friend” and offered to stop drinking with Witt rather than pursue disciplinary action.
The complaint also alleged that Witt agreed not to seek another term on Township Council. He was not named as a defendant in the lawsuit, and the settlement did not establish whether the allegations against him were true.
A separate dispute arose in January 2023 over the hiring of Danielle Spilatore, whom Tozzi alleged Fried pressured her to employ despite the absence of an available position or sufficient funding in the municipal budget.
According to the lawsuit, Fried directed Tozzi to hire Spilatore as an asset manager at an annual salary of $60,000 plus benefits. Tozzi claimed Spilatore subsequently failed to perform assigned duties, took excessive time off and conducted personal business during working hours.
The complaint alleged that Spilatore resigned in September 2023 after approximately five months of employment, following a disagreement over a request for additional time off. Tozzi claimed Fried subsequently pressured her to rehire Spilatore on a part-time basis with benefits, despite concerns about her performance and the lack of an available position.
According to the lawsuit, Spilatore wanted to retain her seat on the township Planning Board, which was contingent on her continued municipal employment. Tozzi maintained that she refused to rehire Spilatore because of concerns about her work performance and the propriety of bringing her back onto the municipal payroll. Spilatore was not named as a defendant, and the allegations about her conduct were not established in court.
According to the complaint, Tozzi’s refusal led to retaliation by Fried and other township officials. She alleged that council members questioned her mental stability and threatened her employment. She also claimed Fried suggested she take additional time off because of supposed emotional problems.
Tozzi subsequently began negotiating a possible resignation but withdrew the offer on Oct. 20, 2023, notifying the township through her attorney that she intended to remain employed. Three days later, Fried issued a letter removing her as township administrator, effective Jan. 21, 2024.
The letter, reproduced in the lawsuit, stated that Tozzi would not be required to report to work during the 90-day period before her termination became effective but would continue receiving her salary.
Tozzi alleged that when she arrived at the municipal building for a budget meeting on Oct. 23, the township police chief told her Fried did not want her in the building and that she could face criminal trespassing charges if she refused to leave. She also claimed the township stopped paying her in December 2023, before the effective date of her termination, despite the letter’s promise of continued compensation.
The lawsuit further alleged that Fried confronted Tozzi at a League of Municipalities event, demanding to know whether he should tell people she had resigned or been fired.
Tozzi filed suit on July 19, 2024, seeking damages for lost wages, emotional distress and other alleged injuries. The complaint maintained that her termination violated the state’s whistleblower law, which protects employees from retaliation for reporting or objecting to conduct they reasonably believe is unlawful.
The litigation continued for more than two years before the parties reached the settlement.
The agreement, which Tozzi signed Sept. 30, also includes provisions barring her from seeking future employment with Robbinsville and restricting disparaging statements by the parties, subject to specified exceptions.
The settlement became the subject of public discussion following its approval in October and the subsequent release of documents through a public records request.
At the Thursday, Nov. 12, Township Council meeting, Mayor Michael Todd said the decision to settle was primarily financial, intended to avoid the expense and uncertainty of continuing the litigation.
Todd said most of the $300,000 payment would be covered by insurance, with the township responsible for a deductible of approximately $75,000. He said the money needed to cover the deductible had already been set aside for litigation in a previous municipal budget. None of the township’s 2026 tax increase was attributable to the settlement, he said.
Todd also emphasized that the settlement did not constitute an admission of wrongdoing and that the township continued to maintain that it had acted properly.
Council President Deborah Blakely defended the township’s handling of the case and addressed questions about the timing of the agreement and its public disclosure.
“Some claims have merit and some do not. A settlement is not an admission of guilt or wrongdoing,” Blakely said.
Blakely said the matter had appeared on council agendas and had been discussed in executive session when appropriate. She disputed suggestions that the settlement had been deliberately withheld until after the November election. She also noted that residents could obtain public documents relating to the settlement by submitting requests under the state’s Open Public Records Act.
“We stand by the process that we all followed, and our commitment to Robbinsville has not changed,” Blakely said.
Fried, who served as Robbinsville’s mayor for nearly 25 years before leaving office in January because he was moving out of town, also addressed the settlement in a Facebook statement, saying he was not involved in the decision to resolve the litigation.
“I did not make the decision to settle this lawsuit,” Fried wrote. “Had the decision been mine, I would have chosen to defend the case rather than settle. Others chose a different path.”
Fried acknowledged that residents had the right to question the decision and the township’s handling of the matter. However, he also criticized personal attacks directed at municipal employees and elected officials following the settlement.
“A township employee has been subjected to degrading comments. She did nothing wrong. She is a person with a family, a reputation and every right to be treated with dignity,” Fried wrote. “Let me be equally clear: if you think you are defending me by demeaning someone else, you are not speaking for me. I do not want that kind of support.”
Fried also condemned personal attacks against Councilman-elect Kiran Agrahara and Councilman Ravi Patni, saying both deserved respect for their willingness to serve the community.
He said public officials should expect scrutiny and criticism but should not be subjected to personal humiliation. He also expressed concern that such behavior could discourage other residents from seeking public office.
“How many thoughtful, capable people watch this behavior and decide that serving their community simply is not worth what it would put their families through?” Fried wrote.
“We all lose when that happens.”
Fried’s statement did not address the specific allegations in Tozzi’s lawsuit beyond his disagreement with the decision to settle.
The agreement closes the case without resolving the competing accounts of what occurred during Tozzi’s employment. The township and Fried have expressly denied engaging in retaliation, discrimination, harassment or other unlawful conduct.
The case was filed in the Law Division of Mercer County Superior Court under docket number MER-L-001407-24. Tozzi was represented by R. Armen McOmber and Austin B. Tobin of McOmber McOmber & Luber in Red Bank.


